Why Does This Keep Happening to Me?

October Special: “Spooky Psychology”, Part 1/3: Threads of Fate: Why Patterns Repeat

Why does this sh*t keep happening to me?”
I hear this question in my practice regularly. The same type of partner, again. The same conflict at work, again. That feeling of being stuck in a badly written play where only the cast changes.

Some call it fate. Psychology calls it behavioural patterns.
And the two have more in common than you might think.

October is the one month when fear gets to play - most of us are more open to the uncanny, and some of us go looking for it. So let’s use that. For one month, we’ll walk the line between what psychology can measure and what it (still) can’t: threads of fate and repeating patterns, trance,
a machete, and a medium in the Black Forest. Scientific where possible. Open where it’s not (yet).

In this special, “Spooky Psychology”, we’ll take three looks behind the surface:

  • What happens when we believe something about ourselves?

  • When we believe in a method?

  • And when we believe a voice from outside?

Today is about the beliefs we hold about ourselves - and how they can run through our lives like a thread. A red one. Or a pink one.

The past shapes the present. It doesn’t write it.

Sounds like a fridge magnet. It happens to be well supported by psychology - and it’s one of the oldest stories humans tell.

Repetition Compulsion: Freud’s Explanation - and Its Limits

Psychoanalysis coined a term for this more than a hundred years ago: repetition compulsion. Freud used it to describe the unconscious tendency to repeat painful experiences or their circumstances - sometimes symbolically, sometimes quite literally.

In fairness: it’s a psychoanalytic concept, not a law of nature, and parts of it are empirically contested. But the pattern behind it - people repeatedly landing in similar constellations - is easy to observe clinically. And it can be explained in a pretty down-to-earth way.

Why Do Patterns Repeat? The Four Gears Behind Them

Attraction? Mechanics! “You don’t attract what you want, you attract what you are.” That line has been floating around social media and manifestation circles for years. It sounds deep. It’s also a bit off. What actually happens is easier to explain - and, more importantly, easier to influence.

Case vignette
Mira is in her mid-thirties and knows her pattern well: the men she falls for are charming, exciting – and emotionally hard to reach. The reliable ones she finds “nice, but somehow boring”. After the third break-up that feels exactly like the first, she asks: “Why does this always happen to me?”

This case vignette is fictional. It condenses a pattern I encounter again and again in my work; people and details are freely composed.

Gear 1:
Early experiences become beliefs about ourselves.
Whether we felt welcome, understood and cared for as children shapes what we later consider normal, deserved and possible.
In Mira’s case: Her father was loving, but rarely there. Attention came mostly when she tried hard and stayed easy-going. What stuck: closeness is something I have to earn.

Gear 2:
Beliefs steer perception.
If you learned “I’m too much,” you’ll register every eye-roll and miss three compliments.
Our brains preferentially collect evidence for what they already believe (confirmation bias) - faster than we can consciously sort things out.
In Mira’s case: She notices every delayed reply to a message. Someone who reliably texts back barely registers - or even makes her suspicious. Whether a suspicion like that is gut feeling or old fear is surprisingly hard to tell from the inside - more on that in my article on gut feeling and intuition.

Gear 3:
Perception steers behaviour.
An example of a self-fulfilling prophecy: if you expect rejection, you act differently - more cautious, more adapted, sometimes pre-emptively distant. And that behaviour - surprise - tends to produce exactly the reactions that confirm the old belief. Sociologist Robert K. Merton named this in 1948: the self-fulfilling prophecy.
In Mira’s case: With attentive partners, she gets cautious and tests whether the affection holds
- until it becomes too exhausting for the other person. With distant ones, she tries harder. Both confirm: closeness is something I have to earn.

Gear 4:
The nervous system holds on to the familiar.
Familiar feels safe - even when it hurts us. A nervous system calibrated to chronic stress can read calm as a threat and drama as home.
In Mira’s case: A calm relationship feels flat. The hoping and fearing, on the other hand, feels like love - because it feels like back then.

Four gears, interlocking.
And here’s the good news: gears can be turned. Cosmic attraction, not so much.

Many Norns, Uneven Threads: Why Some Carry More

Graphic: Urd – what has become. Verdandi – what is becoming. Skuld – what shall be. Psychology knows the same three: Imprints. Patterns. Expectations. With a brain and a pink thread running through it.

Long before developmental psychology, there were the Norns: the women of fate in Norse mythology, sitting at the roots of the world tree, spinning the threads of life.

Most people know three of them:

  • Urd, what has become

  • Verdandi, what is becoming

  • Skuld, what shall be

The more interesting detail usually gets overlooked: in Snorri’s Prose Edda, there are many more. Good Norns and bad Norns
- and they spin unevenly. Some people get light threads. Others get heavy, short, or knotted ones.

Myth and psychology describe the same observation here, in two languages: some people start life carrying far more weight than others. And what has settled - Urd, what has become - keeps spinning itself forward as long as no one looks.

Graphic: Sounds like myth, but it's reality: Family, poverty, early fear – some start out with knotted threads. That's not fair. The question is what can grow from it.

Burdens - lived or inherited - are never distributed fairly. Yes, inherited: unprocessed burdens from earlier generations can leave traces - in parenting, in relationship patterns, in family sentences like “The world is dangerous” or “We just push through.” Whether and how they’re also passed on biologically is something science is only beginning to explore.

How this gets passed on deserves its own article. If you want to go deeper now: my article on black sheep, goats, and systemic resilience looks at how burdens travel through generations - and why the “difficult ones” in a family are often the ones making the unprocessed legacy visible.

Why some people get more to carry stays open. Psychology has no satisfying answer. Philosophy has been arguing about it for a few thousand years. Norse mythology just shrugs: good Norns, bad Norns.

What science can say: how hard your start was doesn’t automatically decide how things go on. And some of what gets passed down is burden and valuable knowledge at once. High alertness from an unsafe childhood can be a real strength in the right context: spotting danger early, reading rooms, sensing a mood before it tips. An adaptation that was once essential for survival
- and today deserves more options.

What Is Magical Thinking? The Psychology Behind It

That manifestation line from above, by the way, is a nice example of what psychology calls magical thinking: the assumption that thoughts, wishes or symbols directly influence the world. In December 2025, I wrote here that belief is neurobiology with a poetic user interface: When Myths and Biology Speak the Same Language. Magical thinking is one of those interfaces - and it shows up in three forms.

Completely normal in childhood.
Children between roughly two and seven take it for granted that their thoughts and wishes influence events. Developmental psychologist Jean Piaget described this as a typical phase. Anyone who believed as a child that they caused their parents’ fights knows its shadow side.

Surprisingly common in adult life.
Knock on wood. Don’t jinx it. Fingers crossed. Psychologists Jane Risen and Thomas Gilovich (2008) showed that even people who consider themselves rational believe you can tempt fate
- for instance by celebrating too early or skipping a precaution.

Clinically relevant when it becomes rigid and distressing.
For example in OCD, when the thought “If I think it, it will happen” gains so much power that rituals seem necessary to ward off the imagined disaster.

And science itself? Not immune either. In 2010, a study made headlines: people with a lucky charm performed better on tasks (Damisch and colleagues). Later, more careful studies couldn’t confirm the effect (Calin-Jageman & Caldwell, 2014). Researchers, too, sometimes like to believe what sounds good.

Seen this way, “fate” is often just a belief that went unchallenged for long enough.

How to Change Patterns: Where You Can Start

Patterns rarely dissolve because we find them annoying. They dissolve when the unconscious becomes conscious - and when, at the exact point where we’d usually react on autopilot, we choose. That’s where healing shows - as far as healing goes.

Even with heavy threads, there's room for choice. The past spins along. But it's not the one directing. Two hands connected by a pink thread that forms a heart around a brain.

A first step: three questions that work directly on the gears.

  • What reaction am I expecting right now - and where do I know it from?

  • What am I collecting evidence for right now - and what am I missing?

  • What would I do if I expected the opposite?

And here’s where it gets interesting.
Insight alone often barely moves the gears. The question that matters: Can I start to believe myself - because I’ve experienced it?

Beliefs change mostly through experience. Through the moment your heart slows down in the presence of a trigger. The moment the old prophecy doesn’t come true - and your body notices.

For Mira, that could mean: on the next date with someone reliable, watching the boredom with curiosity. Maybe it’s calm that just doesn’t feel familiar yet.

Part 2 is about why rituals and inner images work where understanding alone falls short
- from imagery rescripting, an established method in psychotherapy, to the wilder edges of the spectrum. And where openness helps and where scepticism does.

Want to know which patterns keep repeating in your life? That’s what psychological support and therapy are for. And for everything in between, there’s my newsletter - with stories you’ll only find there, like the finale of Spooky Psychology.


Part 2: Cord Cutting Rituals: Why They Work – A Therapist’s View
Part 3: The Medium in the Black Forest

Elena Tinkloh (aka Tink) is a licensed psychotherapist in Germany, specializing in cognitive behavioral therapy, and explores which seemingly mystical phenomena science can explain - and which it can’t (yet).

Elena Tinkloh

Approbierte Psychotherapeutin (VT) · online · DE/EN
Wie du unter Druck fühlst, redest und handelst, lässt sich trainieren.
Seminare · Einzelarbeit · Flow
Own your edge

https://www.PinkPunkPsychology.com
Zurück
Zurück

Cutting the Threads: Why Rituals Work Where Understanding Alone Falls Short

Weiter
Weiter

“I’m a Wrinkly Old Prune” - How Negative Self-Talk Affects Your Mind and Body